ABUJA — The Presidency has said only the United States District Court for the District of Columbia can determine whether records relating to President Bola Tinubu will be released or withheld in an ongoing Freedom of Information Act case, dismissing claims by former Vice President Atiku Abubakar and his representatives.
In a statement issued on Thursday by the Special Adviser to the President on Information and Strategy, Bayo Onanuga, the Presidency said the matter was a civil records-disclosure dispute under US law and not a criminal case against Tinubu.
“The release or withholding of records under FOIA does not, by itself, establish criminal liability,” the Presidency said. “The case concerns access to government records and the proper application of statutory exemptions.”
The clarification followed renewed public debate over proceedings before Judge Beryl A. Howell of the US District Court for the District of Columbia. The case arose from FOIA requests submitted by American transparency advocate Aaron Greenspan to several US agencies seeking records relating to Tinubu and other individuals. Court records show the case is assigned to Judge Howell and concerns whether federal agencies may release, withhold or redact responsive records under FOIA exemptions.
The Presidency insisted that neither Atiku nor Karl von Batten, whose firm has publicly commented on the case, would decide the outcome. It said the court would determine the matter based on evidence, applicable law and arguments filed by the parties.
“She will determine its outcome, based on the evidence, applicable law, and the parties’ arguments, not the wishful preference of Alhaji Atiku Abubakar or his agent, Mr Von Batten,” the statement said.
Onanuga also argued that recent commentaries had wrongly presented the litigation as a criminal proceeding against the President. According to the Presidency, the case does not amount to a charge, trial or judicial finding of wrongdoing against Tinubu.
The long-running FOIA litigation has attracted attention in Nigeria because it relates to US law-enforcement and government records connected to past inquiries involving Tinubu. Reports last week said the court had allowed the FBI to submit some sensitive records privately for in-camera review, a process in which a judge examines documents outside public view before deciding whether they should be disclosed.
Atiku’s camp and other critics have argued that the records are of public interest, while Tinubu’s side has maintained that the case must be handled strictly according to US legal procedures and privacy protections.
The Presidency said the Nigerian public and media should avoid treating the dispute as proof of criminal liability, stressing that FOIA cases deal with access to government information and the limits of disclosure.
The case is expected to remain under close scrutiny in Nigeria’s political space, especially as opposition figures continue to raise questions about transparency. But for now, the central issue before the US court is procedural: whether the requested records should be released, redacted or withheld under American freedom-of-information law.




















