BOSTON — A US federal appeals court has rejected a Trump administration policy that allowed migrants to be deported quickly to third countries without a meaningful chance to raise fears of torture, persecution or other harm.
The Boston-based 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld much of an earlier ruling by US District Judge Brian Murphy, who found that the Department of Homeland Security’s third-country deportation policy was unlawful. The policy, adopted in March 2025, allowed immigration authorities to remove some migrants to countries other than their homelands, including countries where they had no legal status, family ties or prior connection.
The case centres on migrants who could not be deported to their home countries because US immigration courts had found they could face torture or persecution there. Under the challenged policy, the government sought to remove them instead to alternative countries, sometimes with little notice and based on diplomatic assurances from receiving governments.
The appeals court said migrants must be given a meaningful opportunity to challenge deportation to a third country before they are removed. The ruling does not permanently bar every third-country deportation, but it limits the government’s ability to carry them out rapidly without notice and procedural safeguards.
Rights groups argued that the policy exposed vulnerable migrants to serious danger by sending them to countries where they could face detention, onward deportation, mistreatment or return to the places from which US courts had already protected them. One example cited in earlier litigation involved migrants sent to South Sudan despite concerns about their safety and legal status.
The Trump administration defended the policy as part of its broader immigration enforcement strategy, arguing that third-country removals were necessary when migrants could not be returned directly to their countries of origin. DHS has also pursued agreements with other governments willing to accept deportees.
The lawsuit was brought as a class action on behalf of migrants affected by third-country removals. According to Reuters, more than 25,000 migrants have been affected by such deportations, with some sent to countries including Mexico and Uganda under arrangements reached by the administration.
The ruling is another major legal test for President Donald Trump’s expanded deportation agenda. His administration has won some court victories on immigration enforcement, including a separate ruling allowing broader use of expedited removal, but courts have continued to scrutinise policies that limit access to hearings or protection claims.
The case could still reach the US Supreme Court, where the administration may seek permission to revive broader use of the policy.
For migrants facing removal, the decision means the government must provide clearer notice and a real chance to raise country-specific safety claims before sending them to a third country. For the administration, it places another legal constraint on efforts to accelerate deportations beyond migrants’ home countries.



















