WASHINGTON, United States
United States President Donald Trump has suffered a major legal setback after a federal judge permanently dismissed his $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal and media mogul Rupert Murdoch over reporting about an alleged birthday letter to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
US District Judge Darrin Gayles issued the ruling in Miami on Saturday, October 31, concluding that Trump had failed to establish that the newspaper knowingly published false information or acted with reckless disregard for the truth. The judge dismissed the case “with prejudice,” preventing Trump from filing another amended complaint or bringing the same lawsuit again in the district court.
The controversy began in July 2025 when The Wall Street Journal reported that a sexually suggestive birthday greeting bearing Trump’s name appeared in a 2003 album prepared for Epstein’s 50th birthday. The alleged letter contained a drawing outlining a naked woman and a message referring to secrets shared between friends. Trump strongly denied writing the letter, describing the newspaper’s reporting as fabricated, malicious and defamatory. He subsequently sued the Journal, its parent companies, Rupert Murdoch and journalists involved in the investigation, seeking at least $10 billion in damages.
However, Judge Gayles ruled that Trump’s amended complaint failed to meet the legal standard required for public figures pursuing defamation claims. The court highlighted that the newspaper had conducted a detailed investigation, sought Trump’s response before publication and included his denial in its reporting.
Gayles rejected the argument that journalists should have abandoned the story simply because Trump disputed its authenticity. The lawsuit had previously been dismissed in April 2026, but Trump was allowed to revise his allegations and submit an amended complaint in May. Saturday’s ruling marked the second dismissal, this time closing the case at the district court level. Responding to the decision, a spokesperson for Trump’s legal team insisted that the president would continue challenging what he considers false reporting.
Dow Jones, the publisher of The Wall Street Journal, welcomed the ruling. The disputed letter resurfaced in September 2025 when a copy was publicly released by the House Oversight Committee after being obtained from Epstein’s estate. The court’s decision did not establish whether Trump actually wrote the letter. Instead, it focused on whether the newspaper’s reporting met the legal threshold for defamation. Although the dismissal prevents another filing of the same case in the district court, Trump retains the option of appealing the ruling. The decision highlights the substantial legal protections afforded to investigative journalism under the United States Constitution.



















