KANSAS CITY — The International Football Association Board (IFAB) has acknowledged that Switzerland forward Breel Embolo was wrongly sent off during his team’s 2026 FIFA World Cup quarter-final defeat to Argentina, after VAR was used incorrectly in the controversial incident.
The clarification came in an IFAB circular issued on Tuesday, following renewed debate over the expanded use of “mistaken identity” during the tournament. The football law-making body said the VAR protocol did not permit officials to reassess the offence itself once the correct player had been identified.
The incident occurred on July 11 at Kansas City Stadium with the quarter-final tied at 1-1. Argentina midfielder Leandro Paredes was initially booked by Portuguese referee Joao Pinheiro after a challenge involving Embolo. VAR subsequently advised a review, after which Paredes’ caution was cancelled and Embolo was booked for simulation.
Because Embolo had already received a yellow card in the first half, the second caution resulted in his dismissal. Switzerland were forced to play the remainder of the match with 10 men, eventually losing 3-1 after Argentina scored twice in extra time.
IFAB said the mistaken-identity provision can be used when officials have cautioned the wrong player, but cannot be invoked simply to change the nature of the original offence.
“The offence itself cannot be reviewed / changed.”
According to the clarification, the error in Kansas City was that officials overturned the initial decision even though there was no mistake concerning the identity of the player who had been sanctioned.
The controversy has particular significance because the VAR intervention came when Switzerland had begun to recover from Argentina’s early advantage. The Swiss were level after Dan Ndoye’s second-half equaliser before Embolo’s dismissal shifted the balance of the game.
Switzerland coach Murat Yakin had strongly criticised the decision immediately after the match, arguing that the application of the rule had adversely affected his team’s chances.
“It destroyed our game today. We have to accept it, but it’s painful to lose that way.”
IFAB said the use of the mistaken-identity provision during the World Cup would be examined as part of a broader review of VAR protocols, but stressed that the interpretation used in Embolo’s case should not be applied again until that review is completed.



















